Automated testing is crucial to the development of software that meets the requirements of today's users. They guarantee the stability, performance and reliability of websites and applications.
However, with so many tools at your disposal for test execution, it can be complicated to choose the solution that best suits your QA needs.
In this article, we'll look at three automated test platforms: Mr Suricate Alfred Monitoring and Tosca, each with its own unique test automation features.
Mr Suricate - French leader in no-code automated testing
Created in 2016, Mr Suricate 's no-code solution for automated cross-browser & cross-device testing lets you easily test apps and websites across browsers, operating systems and mobile platforms.
It stands out for its ease of use, with an intuitive interface that makes it accessible even to testers with little or no coding experience.
The no-code platform lets anyone create automated test scripts, run them on different browsers, and analyze the detailed results.
Key benefits of Mr Suricate
✅ All-in-one solution
Mr Suricate offers comprehensive coverage, enabling the detection of potential bugs for web, mobile application, API, accessibility, SEO, visual or performance aspects.
✅ No-code editor (pre-coded actions) with scenario recorder
Its no-code approach, based on pre-established templates, saves time when creating tests.
The scenario recorder lets you quickly create test scripts and generate detailed documentation, while reducing the risk of human error that can occur when manually writing scripts.
✅ Widget-based dashboards with advanced custom alerts
Users of Mr Suricate users can create customized dashboards using widgets specific to their needs. Thanks to the advanced alert system (SMS, Slack, Teams, etc.), testers are informed immediately when a test fails, exceeds a predefined threshold or when undesirable behavior is detected.
✅ Dedicated Customer Success Manager + live chat support
Mr Suricate offers personalized support and assistance from A to Z in using the platform. Specialists are based in France and can navigate Salesforce clouds.
There's also a chat support team on hand to deal with queries as they arise.
✅ Reversibility plan available for open source platforms (Selenium, Playwright)
This allows users to benefit from the advantages of proprietary technology, while at the same time offering the possibility of leveraging popular frameworks for greater flexibility.
✅ Can be used for non-regression testing and all your testing and monitoring needs in one product
For both business and IT contexts, Mr Suricate can be used for all your testing requirements, all on one centralized platform.
✅ Fixed price each month
Mr Suricate offers an all-inclusive fixed monthly rate, including installation, maintenance, customer relationship management and consulting.
✅ Duration of existence
Mr Suricate has been active since 2016, benefiting from 7 years of user and customer feedback.
The disadvantages of Mr Suricate
❌ Customization limitations
Although Mr Suricate offers a simplified approach to test creation, this may limit the customization of highly advanced test scenarios for more experienced testers looking for additional functionality.
❌ "Fat client" tests are not supported
Mr Suricate allows you to carry out exhaustive tests on web applications, but other aspects of the system are not taken into account.
For example, tests related to network infrastructure or applications not accessible via the web are not taken into account. However, a VPN gateway is an alternative solution for getting around this limitation.
Alfred Monitoring - Monitoring customer experiences on real devices
Alfred Monitoring is a functional path monitoring platform focused on the user experience , which enables you to identify the functionalities to be tested, set up a configuration and launch a monitoring campaign.
Monitoring campaigns can be scheduled on a recurring or ad hoc basis, and in the event of a malfunction, alerts are sent in real time.
Alfred Monitoring's key benefits
✅ Fixed price
You pay a fixed amount per month per scenario. This scenario can be run as many times as you like for any environment, browser or configuration.
✅ 2 reporting levels
An overview that lets you compare results by functionality, browser and environment.
For a more in-depth look at the aspects requiring more attention, there's also a detailed view (scenarios, steps, data) to identify the origin and cause of the malfunction, supported by screenshots.
✅ Testing customer journeys on real mobile devices
This capability enables the detection of bugs specific to certain models or operating systems, which is crucial to guaranteeing optimal compatibility and consistent performance on all devices.
The disadvantages of Alfred Monitoring
❌ Web only (not all-in-one)
The platform only supports web testing, limiting the possibilities for testing other types of applications.
❌ Using Selenium and Serenity BDD
Requires technical knowledge to create test scripts.
❌ Basic report, no off-report alerting
Reports are limited and there is no alert system outside the reports, which can delay detection of critical problems.
❌ Based outside France and no chat support
Customer support is limited in terms of availability and responsiveness, with no chat support.
❌ No reversibility/internalisation
The platform does not offer reversibility plans or insourcing options, which limits flexibility.
❌ Available only since 2021
Limited experience on the market, which may raise questions about the platform's maturity and stability.
Tricentis Tosca - Optimize and accelerate end-to-end testing
Tosca, a continuous test automation tool that is part of the Tricentis platform, is designed to optimize and accelerate end-to-end testing across all digital environments.
Tosca covers all digital initiatives, including cloud migration, modernization of core business applications and UX optimization.
Its no-code, AI-driven approach is designed to eliminate testing bottlenecks and the risks associated with software releases.
Key benefits of Tosca
✅ Script recorder available
Allows you to easily create test scripts, but without conditions and unable to track dynamic objects.
✅ Intuitive dashboards
Provides dashboards for visualizing test data, facilitating analysis and performance monitoring.
✅ Numerous options and additional services
The high cost can be a deterrent, although the platform offers many additional options and services that may justify the investment for some companies.
Tosca's disadvantages
❌ One license per requirement
Not all-in-one. The offer is compartmentalized into different products, requiring a separate license for each specific need, which can complicate management and increase costs.
❌ No customer service
The learning center is available through videos, but lacks live support for immediate, personalized assistance.
❌ Proprietary technology and no reversibility plan
Uses proprietary technology with no possibility of reverting to an open source solution, limiting flexibility and independence for users.
Which one to choose?
With the different features and capabilities when comparing Mr Suricate vs Alfred Monitoring vs Tosca, it's essential to carefully consider project needs and team strengths before making a decision.
Mr Suricate - For companies looking for a complete no-code solution
Mr Suricate stands out for its no-code approach, all-in-one solution and dedicated customer support.
It's an excellent choice for companies looking for a comprehensive, easy-to-use solution, with advanced features like customizable dashboards and real-time alerts.
Its reversibility plan for open source platforms offers additional flexibility.
Alfred Monitoring - For companies seeking to guarantee UX
With its testing capabilities on real mobile devices, Alfred Monitoring is particularly well-suited to companies looking for a simple solution focused on the user experience.
Its fixed pricing per scenario and detailed reporting provide clear visibility of performance and predictable costs.
Tosca - Optimizing E2E tests
Tosca is ideal for companies looking to optimize and accelerate end-to-end testing.
Its AI-driven, continuous test automation platform covers a wide range of digital initiatives. Although expensive, Tosca offers many additional options and services.
Mr Suricate | A multi-browser, multi-device automated test solution
The great added value of Mr Suricate is to combine its SaaS solution with quality service, enabling a non-IT specialist to become a tester in less than a month.
With Mr Suricateyou don't need to know how to code or spend a fortune to make sure your users have a smooth and bug-free browsing experience, no matter how they access it!
